The passing last week of Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen – famous for his theory of business disruption - is a good time to consider business risk. Specifically, what are the risks faced by your business during a transition in ownership.
For background, A visit to the Christensen Institute website finds this definition of the business school professor’s theory: “Disruptive Innovation describes a process by which a product or service initially takes root in simple applications at the bottom of a market—typically by being less expensive and more accessible—and then relentlessly moves upmarket, eventually displacing established competitors.”
Fear of disruption often is ignored. A business thinks it is well established, has strong customer relationships, unique products, special services. It is insulated from disruption. Right?
There are plenty of examples to the contrary: newspapers; video rental stores; land line phone companies. Every owner needs to be sensitive to the danger. When it is time to a business sale, every buyer will focus on areas of risk to decide whether to go forward or not.
Let’s look at a couple.
Revenue generation. Can the business perpetuate the revenue it currently generates? Are there ways to grow it in the future. These two points are fundamental to getting a successful transaction.
Owners who have given this question thought can share what they have done through the years to make revenue reliable, and what they believe is possible to preserve in years ahead. Many small companies developed in an age where there was little if any shopping. But the internet has opened up opportunities for buyers to look around.
If you have time to prepare, look for ways to make your business “sticky” with the customers. Offer services that are hard to replace. Turn orders around more quickly, or provide a level of customization that bigger outfits can’t provide. You get the idea.
Customer concentration. It is not uncommon for a business to cater to needs of reliable customers. But it is not a good idea to become too reliant on one customer. This refers to a customer producing over 20% of a company’s revenue.
Distribution of customer business gets close scrutiny by prospective buyers. In general, a broad blend of customers is better than a handful of major ones. If there is a concentration issue, there are methods to address it.
First, disclose it. Second, identify real reasons why it is an opportunity, not just a risk. Third, be agreeable to efforts by a buyer to address it in the Letter of Intent and the final agreement.
A buyer may ask to review contracts to see if they can be transferred. It is a given that in diligence you will need to provide detailed records on the customer’s activities. It is also almost certain that an introduction to major customer(s) will be requested before the closing of a sale. Although scary and risky, this introduction is where the rubber meets the road.
If you have time to prepare, look for ways to ease the concentration by broadening the customer base.
Ongoing management. It is very common in small companies for the owner to be the key decision maker and the top salesperson. However, this represents a risk to a buyer. And it sometimes is a deal killer.
A management team, or second in command, is very desirable. It enhances value. One private equity group told us they will not even consider an acquisition that lacks a management team or successor manager in place. This is not universal, but it is a key indicator of the value of having management in place.
A company with an operations manager or team will get a higher multiple in a transaction. This individual or group can carry on the operation without the owner’s direct involvement, making an acquisition less risky for the buyer. Plus, if the team has a vision for growth, it is even better.
A strategic buyer in the same industry may have “people” to deploy, but they will still want someone steeped in the current business who can carry on through a transition.
If you have time to prepare, consider putting a second in command or management team in place to help with day to day decisions. Good places to start are operations and sales. This way the owner is not directly responsible for everything that will be critical for a buyer.
Risk is part of every business acquisition, and there are many ways to address it. In the end, it will be reflected in deal terms expressed in the definitive agreement. Two significant ways are for an “owner earnout” based on retention of critical customers or a performance bonus paid to the owner over several years based on sales.
"The entire process went smoothly and professionally. The BTS team kept me fully informed at every step. They worked hard and were effective in bringing the deal home."
"Skip and I continue to be grateful for all you have done to make the sale of Pure Flow come to fruition."
"BTS’s level of expertise in the process and close attention to detail enabled us to successfully navigate the deal."
"These types of transactions are often long and complicated and I doubt it could have been successfully completed without your close ongoing involvement."
"The outside objective point of view that you have brought us has been invaluable as we prepare for the rapid growth."
"John then found the right buyer and coordinated a seamless transition—he doesn’t miss a single detail."
"John immediately identified our strengths and experiences and discussed a business that ultimately was more in line with our goals."
"The BTS team came in, evaluated everything in a professional and thankfully non-threatening manner."
Questions That Owners Consider
We have had many conversations with business owners in the lower mid-market who are unsure about the future and wonder whether they should sell or hold.
SBA Debt Relief Incentivizes Buyers
SBA debt relief efforts are incentivizing buyers to move ahead with business acquisitions.
Don’t Let the Pandemic Sideline Your Dreams
As we emerge from the Covid 19 shut downs, some may be fearing “oh no, I am stuck in the saddle again.” We think there is reason to look at the horizon more positively. That involves taking actio
Prepare for the Market Rebound
For many business owners, the economic effects of the COVID-19 pandemic have been devastating – especially for those who were planning to sell their businesses.
Using Downtime to Add Value
As business owners are working to process the impact of COVID-19, we’re looking at how it will affect M&A. The good news is that many companies and private equity firms have been doing well for year
Are Buyers Still in the Market?
We believe that mergers and acquisitions will continue once the current crisis ends...based on the volume of inquiries from private equity funds, search funds and well-funded individual buyers.
Use the Threat to Better Prepare
Today there is a lot of uncertainty about the future of business...there are things you can do to prepare for an eventual sale of your company– especially now.
Crisis Shows Ripple Effect of Business
Our focus at BTS is on small companies that are the backbone of the economy...This gives us exceptional insight into what it is like to be owner-operators.
Dealing with risks in a company sale
The passing last week of Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen – famous for his theory of business disruption - is a good time to consider business risk.
M&A Advisor Tip: Earnouts Can Break a Deadlock
Earnouts can be used to address a perception of risk faced by a buyer. They also are used to bridge a valuation gap between a buyer and a seller.
Precision Machining Company
Initially, liquidation was a serious consideration. It would offer a quick exit but would hurt loyal employees and disrupt the customers who had come to rely on its quality production.
Green Product Company
Our client owners could dig in for the long haul…However, this would take five years or more. Owners simply lacked the horsepower to do it.
Water Purification Company and Young Buyers
Owners decided they wanted to retire. They also wanted to be fair to the staff who had been loyal to them. Could the company be sold, the staff retained and the facility remain in use?
Magnetics Company with High Profile Customers
(T)he manufacturer would need to focus on growing EBITDA to capture interest from major strategic buyers and achieve a higher multiple of earnings.