by John Howe
Taking the ESOP route is not an all or nothing approach to business ownership transition.
A presentation “Comparing the Big Exit Decision” by Steve Cohen, Esq and Tabitha Croscut, Esq. at AMAA New England in Boston September 28 made this clear. The two attorneys with Devine Millimet engaged in a back and forth, point counter-point discussion that brought to light the advantages and disadvantages of choosing to pursue an ESOP or a third-party sale.
Owners could choose to sell a minority of their company to the Employee Stock Ownership Program while remaining in charge of the company. This is a great way to develop liquidity as part of a bigger transition plan. The owner sells part of the company to an ESOP and pulls capital locked in the company out for financial planning. This counters the proverbial all-your-eggs-in-one basket approach many owners face, where year after year they pour their capital back into their company rather than having a diversity of investments for retirement.
In the example mentioned above, it is still possible for the company to be sold down the road, even with an ESOP in place. A full ESOP transfer has some strong offsetting tax advantages, and can enable owners to essentially sell their entity to the employees, which can create tremendous goodwill for everyone if the company is healthy.
However, I would argue a full ESOP will not generate the maximum return for the owner. Attorney Cohen made this point clearly. A third-party sale, run through an M&A process that identifies multiple interested parties and generates a range of proposals, can be very effective in identifying the true value of a company in the marketplace at the time.
Strategic and synergistic buyers will often put a price on a company that exceeds the ESOP valuation, generating even more liquidity for the owner.
It is also arguable that a third-party sale would open even more opportunity for existing employees and management. The mantra in an acquisition is growing and expanding the acquired entity.
A properly positioned management team and crew can leverage a change in ownership into an opportunity to ratchet up their game to hit a new level of business. Contrast this to the attitude of mature private entities where the motivation sometimes is focused more on preservation than growth.
On the other hand, as Attorney Croscut argued, an ESOP can preserve jobs and a company’s position in a community. Sometimes the fear is a sale will result in efficiencies, job losses and upheaval as new owners seek profitability from the purchased entity. This fear can be gut-wrenching for owners in a sale.
Growth and new opportunity is possible under an ESOP transition. In this scenario, the management needs to keep its eye on the ball to maintain revenue and the company’s market position for the good of the beneficiaries of the ESOP. And there will be a trustee checking things out on a regular basis.
It is good to have options, and a solid company can be transitioned in various ways.
"The entire process went smoothly and professionally. The BTS team kept me fully informed at every step. They worked hard and were effective in bringing the deal home."
"Skip and I continue to be grateful for all you have done to make the sale of Pure Flow come to fruition."
"BTS’s level of expertise in the process and close attention to detail enabled us to successfully navigate the deal."
"These types of transactions are often long and complicated and I doubt it could have been successfully completed without your close ongoing involvement."
"The outside objective point of view that you have brought us has been invaluable as we prepare for the rapid growth."
"John then found the right buyer and coordinated a seamless transition—he doesn’t miss a single detail."
"John immediately identified our strengths and experiences and discussed a business that ultimately was more in line with our goals."
"The BTS team came in, evaluated everything in a professional and thankfully non-threatening manner."
Looking Back to Plan the Future
As one year closes; another is just beginning. It is an excellent time for company owners to consider the options for what is next.
Growth Through Acquisition in the Lower Mid-market
Growth through acquisition has been a strategy largely used by mid-sized and larger companies for years. Now firms in the lower mid-market are getting into it as well.
PEI Cites 8 Attributes of Quality Deals
Quality deal flow is among the top concerns for M&A advisors. A recent blog posted by Private Equity Information offers 8 key attributes of “quality deals.”
In an M&A Program: Why Consider a Business “Carve Out”?
An M&A program need not be limited in the search to the complete acquisition of a company.
The BIA Report on Consumer Confidence
"NH consumer confidence remains high" according to the latest BIA Survey conducted October 10 and October 18, 2018 by the UNH Survey Center.
Business Transition Snippets
Here are a few observations we culled from sources we regularly review that relate to business transitions.
What to expect in the LOI exclusivity period
A question that often emerges when reviewing proposals for acquisition with owners is the exclusivity period.
Growth through acquisition isn't just for the big companies
Growth through acquisition Is a valid strategy for businesses in the lower mid-market as well as the mid-market.
The exit decision- timing and issues
When should a business owner start thinking about planning their exit? Early! This is a high-stakes decision and should not be first contemplated when it is imminent.
April PEG investments
It is interesting to watch trends in private equity investments. In general, they reflect confidence in the value of making things. Transactions give insights on the broader acquisition environment, p
Precision Machining Company
Initially, liquidation was a serious consideration. It would offer a quick exit but would hurt loyal employees and disrupt the customers who had come to rely on its quality production.
Green Product Company
Our client owners could dig in for the long haul…However, this would take five years or more. Owners simply lacked the horsepower to do it.
Water Purification Company and Young Buyers
Owners decided they wanted to retire. They also wanted to be fair to the staff who had been loyal to them. Could the company be sold, the staff retained and the facility remain in use?
Magnetics Company with High Profile Customers
(T)he manufacturer would need to focus on growing EBITDA to capture interest from major strategic buyers and achieve a higher multiple of earnings.